The Deadly Viper Controversy… *sigh*
My thoughts on the Deadly Viper controversy…
Honestly, I first thought, “I wish this wasn’t a controversy.” But that’s my first thought every time there’s a controversy… I don’t really like conflict. I’ve kept reading and I’ve come quite a ways from that first impression. I’m glad that we’re having this conversation, I’m glad that brothers and sisters of Asian descent have clued the rest of us in on their hearts and this great mistake in communication and publishing.
And a mistake it is. I have not read the content of the book, but then I don’t see this as a content mistake; by all accounts the content gets good reviews. I don’t personally know the authors, but I’m comfortable saying that was not a mistake of intent; they did not set out to be offensive and plenty folks say what good people they are. But surely, this was a mistake of wisdom, what our great tribe of believers across the world and generations has called discernment.
I recognize that kind of a mistake because it hits home with me. I really don’t usually whiff it on the knowledge base. I rarely intend to do wrong. But I’ve been known to blow it on the wisdom of things; I have been too often guilty of a mistake in discernment not to recognize the signs.
I have taken a couple of days to put myself in the shoes of my Asian descended sisters and brothers, and I empathize with the sting of the images and misuse of elements within their cultures and heritages. This wasn’t a conversation between friends; it was a publishing house putting offensive stereotypes and hurtful allusions into the hands of many people who were expected to laugh at those cultural images and illustrations. That’s painful. It was probably not what the authors expected from their meetings in preparing the book. But the book left the safe confines of meetings and drawing boards and entered the public arena. They did not do good discernment. They were not wise. And I have too many friends of Asian descent and am a pastor to many good people of Asian descent not to make an attempt to understand how painful this may be for them. As their friend and pastor I am doing my own soul-searching to see what changes I may not have realized I need to make in my own life and discernments.
Back to mistakes of wisdom… I’ve had great ideas that went on to blow up and land me in worlds of hurtful, unintended consequences. My knowledge was usually pretty tight, and my intentions were stellar… my wisdom was not up to par. When those kinds of mistakes happen, it’s called “Learning Humility.” Humility hurts. Humility is not a quaint Bible study. It’s when reality is introduced to us, shakes our hands and kicks our butts. Humility lessons suck old egg.
But wait, Humility doesn’t stop at sucking egg, it’s also horribly necessary. We need those humility lessons to grow. They remind us to wrap our gifts and abilities in the Spirit of God, over and over again. Those kinds of mistakes can be admitted, owned, and repented of, thereby opening new avenues for God to work through us and do greater things than we have seen and done.
So, I believe the authors need to embrace the humility that demands they repent of their mistake. Let this be a growth moment. It’s not the end of their publishing careers, it’s a potential point of great change for the better. Imagine what two writers of greater wisdom and discernment might accomplish with their obvious gifts and abilities! And they owe it to their spiritual family! We aren’t just all consumers and marketers here, with apologies to the good folks at Zondervan! This is an opportunity to forge the kinds of friendships-out-of-pain that make us a better community of faith around the globe. Embrace the Humility! Humility is a good thing.
In case you haven’t read up on it, here are some helpful links:
Deadly Viper’s Website
Deadly Viper’s Blog
An Open Letter to the Authors (Prof. Rah)
Just Another White WordPresser Like Me I Found by Googling the Controversy (But he says good stuff)
4 thoughts on “The Deadly Viper Controversy… *sigh*”
November 4, 2009 at 6:26 pm
This is great, Todd, thanks.
In my opinion, this provides a fantastic opportunity for a group of people who clearly didn’t have a clue that what they were doing was offensive to be schooled in a very big way. IF they will allow themselves to be truly humbled and listen. I don’t know these guys, but their branding in general is a pretty big turnoff to me. We’ll see what happens.
November 4, 2009 at 6:47 pm
It is an eye-opener! I’m hoping for healing. It seems there has been some “coming to the table” planned by the authors… so, we can be prayerful!
By the way, it was a status post of yours that first clued me in on the whole situation! Thanks!
November 6, 2009 at 10:22 am
[…] Brink, who linked to reflections from Dan Iwao, Todd Thomas, Marian Wang, Edward Gilbreath, Dave Ingland, LT […]
June 21, 2010 at 2:33 pm
I came across your blog just googling the “Deadly Viper controversy” and I think it’s easy to sit back and criticize a book you haven’t read (at least you said you didn’t read it…I hope you have by now), and I think it’s ridiculous for you to pretend to walk in Asian believer’s because you aren’t Asian, so I guess you could walk in their shoes all you want, but you’re not going to feel what it’s like to be Asian, so for you to try and empathize and I guess feel their pain, is somewhat silly to me.
From what you wrote to Amy’s comment it’s like you’re just sitting back commenting on stuff you don’t know about because you both talk about not being familiar with the book or authors. I read the book and saw nothing offensive in it. I don’t think they made any poor decisions with the branding of the book and I’m sad that it became an issue. I agree with your first thought, saying, “I wish this wasn’t a controversy.” True statement! But it would have been great to stop there.
By the way, with taking offense, everyone will have their opinion and various people get offended by different things. I just don’t think it’s very wise to write a blog about something you admittedly didn’t know much about. I know I’m late in the conversation and I should probably be doing something more constructive with my time than googling stuff like this and reading an almost 6 month old blog post by a stranger and commenting on it, but I don’t do this all the time so I figure it’s ok.
No offense of course.